meta is facing criticism for its inaugural ai image generator,
muse image. the new model allows anyone to use your content by default if you’re an adult with a public instagram account. doing so is apparently as simple as tagging a public profile in the meta ai app and prompting the chatbot to generate new images based on photos from that account.
on july 7, meta joined the ranks of many other ai image generators on the market — including the successor to google’s viral sensation,
nano banana 2 — with the launch of the first media generation models developed by its superintelligence labs: muse image and muse video.
meta says muse image “uses advanced reasoning to understand complex prompts, seamlessly blending multiple photos into high-quality creations you can download and share anywhere — including directly to your chat, story or feed.”
critics, on the other hand, are concerned about non-consensual image manipulation. adults with public instagram accounts were automatically opted in. unless they opt out, people can use their published photos to create new ai images.
the backlash came swiftly, with users expressing their displeasure on social media. as one
wrote on x, “pulling real users into generated photos without explicit consent is a privacy landmine waiting to detonate.”
technology advocates and talent agencies also raised concerns about privacy and consent.
donald campbell, director of advocacy at the tech justice non-profit foxglove, told the
bbc that the move was an “obvious recipe for disaster.” creative artists agency reportedly called for meta to make the feature opt-in rather than opt-out,
saying in a statement, “no one’s name, image, likeness, voice or creative work should be used by any third party, including ai models, without clear, documented consent. true innovation puts creators first: respecting their rights, protecting their livelihoods, and giving them real control, not handing it over to platforms.”