why washing produce won't save you from the parasite causing 'watery diarrhea' in u.s. and quebec
4 minute read
imported herbs, such as basil and cilantro, have been linked to outbreaks of cyclosporiasis in the past.
scott olson/getty images
the gastrointestinal disease that has reportedly sickened thousands in more than half of u.s. states could be spreading in canada, but there hasn’t been an outbreak because we’re not detecting it, says a canadian food safety expert. quebec is now reporting an increase in cases of cyclosporiasis and though other canadian public health officials haven’t noted an uptick, “it could be an ‘if you don’t look, you don’t find’ sort of thing,” says keith warriner, a professor at the university of guelph’s department of food science.
“to say that we’re protected in canada, i’m not sure that’s quite true for the simple reason that when you get non-travel-related cyclospora, that must mean it’s a food vehicle,” says warriner. “we could say, ‘well, it must be strawberries. it must be raspberries. it must be herbs, like basil and cilantro,’ but no one’s actually able to identify that yet (in the u.s.). and for all we know, we could have multiple outbreaks going on at the same time.”
imported berries, herbs and pre-packaged salad mix have been linked to outbreaks of cyclosporiasis, but any produce in contact with people or sewage could be a vehicle. “even oysters,” says warriner.
washing with water, while a sound food safety practice and effective at removing debris, insects and pesticides, “doesn’t really cut it” with pathogens such as cyclospora, e. coli and salmonella, says warriner. he notes that it takes 100 to 500 cyclospora oocysts to cause illness. “to give you perspective, you can get 50,000 oocysts on a needle pinhead. (washing) is not going to do that much.”
there’s a theory that the cyclospora oocysts — the infectious stage of the microscopic parasite — “are extra sticky,” so they adhere to fresh produce and are carried along. “the thing about the oocysts is that they’re super tolerant,” says warriner. they can withstand bleach, various sanitizers and even wastewater treatment.
advertisement
cooking and freezing (at -20 degrees celsius for roughly seven days), however, can neutralize them, which doesn’t suit all purposes. seeking “a firewall” between the source and the consumer, warriner developed a hydroxyl radical technology that uses hydrogen peroxide, uv light and ozone to inactivate parasites on soft fruit and vegetables.
a cyclosporiasis outbreak has now reportedly sickened more than 3,000 people in 31 u.s. states, causing “watery diarrhea,” nausea and fatigue. michigan, which borders ontario, is the hardest-hit state with more than 2,600 cases. the centers for disease control and prevention said it had received reports of 843 confirmed cases of the food- and waterborne intestinal illness, and was aware of more than 1,500 requiring further analysis. the source is still under investigation, and no deaths have been reported.
the public health agency of canada (phac) said in an email to national post on july 13 that it “is not currently investigating any cyclospora outbreaks in canada.” according to tva nouvelles, public health officials in quebec “recently reported an unusual surge in cases.”
cyclosporiasis, a gastrointestinal disease caused by the parasite cyclospora, is most common in tropical and subtropical regions. though the parasite isn’t commonly found on food or in water in canada, phac noted that domestic cases increase in spring and summer as people eat more imported fresh fruit and vegetables.
phac said that canadians can reduce the risk of cyclosporiasis by following safe food handling practices, cooking produce from countries with cyclospora, and eating locally grown fruit and vegetables, especially at this time of year when there’s an increase in infections linked to consuming imported fresh produce.
an average of 238 cases of cyclosporiasis were reported annually in canada between 2004 and 2019. phac says that travellers who eat fresh produce and drink untreated water in high-risk countries are most susceptible.
advertisement
“cyclospora season,” the time of greatest contamination risk, runs from may to the end of august, says warriner. before roughly 2015, cyclosporiasis “was very rare.” occasional outbreaks were linked to imported foods, including basil, cilantro and raspberries. most canadian cases were picked up while on holidays in high-risk countries, when people drank contaminated water, ate contaminated produce or used contaminated ice.
today, canada imports a lot of fresh produce from mexico, central and south america, where there are endemic populations of cyclospora, says warriner. cyclosporiasis is primarily transmitted by the fecal-oral route. poor sanitation and flooding in these regions facilitate the spread. “cyclospora only replicates in us, so it’s in sewage. so, at some point, sewage has to contact the water, contact fresh produce.”
some people wash their produce at home in a bleach solution, which isn’t recommended. “bleach is used extensively in the fresh produce sector in north america but in a controlled way,” says warriner. “in domestic situations, the dose of chlorine is hard to control and likely to generate chlorinated disinfection byproducts that are carcinogenic.” cyclospora oocysts are also highly resistant to chlorine.
to reduce the risk of cyclosporiasis, warriner recommends paying attention to the country of origin when buying fresh produce, especially between may and august, when foods grown in mexico, central and south america are more likely to carry the parasite. when on holiday in high-risk countries, visit a health-care centre for treatment if you suspect you have cyclosporiasis.
“i think one of the good things about being in canada is that a lot of the soft fruit we’re getting now is obviously homegrown,” he says. “and in the u.s., apart from texas, maybe a bit of california, where they’re starting to get endemic populations of cyclospora, all the rest is safe.”
advertisement
some experts have warned that cuts to public health funding could hinder the u.s. investigation into the cyclosporiasis outbreak. warriner notes that even before the current administration began reducing budgets, a spike in outbreaks was an issue. “i don’t think cutbacks are the key. i think what we need is more control at the source, as in stop your crops getting contaminated and get these firewalls in place.”
our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. please bookmark nationalpost.com and sign up for our newsletters here.
share story
