what are the key differences between group and individual disability insurance?
the choice between group and individual disability insurance depends on various factors, including an individual’s health, financial situation, job stability and personal preference
3 minute read
according to a canadian life and health insurance association 2023 report, 68 percent of policies are sold as group plans, which provide coverage for a group of employees, or members of a union or association—under one contract.
getty images
if you’re thinking of retiring soon, change jobs frequently, or have just lost your job, a pressing question for you may be: what’s the difference between group and individual disability insurance plans?
one obvious answer is that group disability insurance is typically offered by employers as part of a benefits package, whereas individual disability insurance is purchased independently by you, the policyholder.
another key difference is cost. group disability insurance is generally less expensive for the employee because the employer often subsidizes a portion of the premium. individual disability insurance, on the other hand, tends to be more costly, since the policyholder bears the full expense.
eligibility and qualifying criteria also differ. group policies usually have more lenient underwriting requirements, making it easier for employees to qualify for coverage. individual policies require more detailed medical underwriting, which can result in higher premiums or denial of coverage based on health conditions.
coverage customization is another important distinction. group disability insurance offers limited customization options, as the plan is designed to meet the needs of a broad group of employees. individual disability insurance allows for more tailored coverage options, enabling policyholders to select specific features and riders that suit their personal needs.
advertisement
group disability insurance is generally not portable, meaning coverage ends when the employee leaves the company, while individual disability insurance remains in force regardless of employment status, providing continuous protection.
benefit amounts and duration can also vary between the two types of policies. group disability insurance often provides a fixed percentage of the employee’s salary, which may be capped at a certain amount. individual policies can offer more flexible benefit amounts and durations, allowing for higher income replacement and longer benefit periods, if desired.
tax implications also differ. benefits received from group disability insurance are typically taxable if the employer pays the premiums. in contrast, benefits from individual disability insurance are usually tax-free if the policyholder pays the premiums with after-tax dollars.
according to a canadian life and health insurance association 2023 report, 68 percent of policies are sold as group plans, which provide coverage for a group of employees, or members of a union or association—under one contract. another 32 percent are sold as individual policies, which provide coverage for one person or a family.
advertisement
in 2022, canada’s life and health insurers paid out $43.9 billion in total health benefits, the clhia report shows. of that amount, $9.4 billion in short and long-term disability payments was paid out to 12 million individuals.
the choice between group and individual disability insurance depends on various factors, including an individual’s health, financial situation, job stability and personal preferences.
while group policies are generally cheaper, they may offer less flexibility in terms of coverage options. individual policies, although more expensive, allow for more customization to fit the specific needs and circumstances of the policyholder. this can include choices in benefit periods, waiting periods and additional riders.
it’s also important to consider the long-term costs. group policies are usually tied to employment, meaning that if you change jobs, you might lose your coverage. individual policies, while initially more expensive, provide continuous coverage regardless of employment status, potentially offering better value over the long term.
for many, a combination of both types of coverage may offer the best protection, leveraging the affordability of group insurance, while supplementing it with the comprehensive benefits of an individual policy.
advertisement
by carefully evaluating the pros and cons of each option, individuals can make informed decisions that best safeguard their financial future in the event of a disability.
nainesh kotak, is the founder of kotak personal injury law, a firm focusing on protecting their client’s rights to justice and obtaining the compensation their clients deserve. he was past chair of the long-term disability section of the ontario trial lawyers’ association.
share story
